Jesus Wars: Councils Defining Christian Beliefs for 1,500 Years

The Fifth-Century Political Battles That Forever Changed the Church

In this captivating narrative, Philip Jenkins unveils the surprisingly violent dynamics that unfolded within the fifth-century church, where a small group of influential figures orchestrated political maneuvers that irrevocably shaped Christian doctrine. Remarkably, had the outcome of these battles been different, the church of today could have been teaching something vastly distinct about the essence of Jesus, and the very existence of the papacy as we know it might have been precluded.

The story begins with the Roman Empire, which had long grappled with the complexities of Christianity. As the faith spread and gained prominence, various factions jockeyed for power, each seeking to assert their interpretation of Christian theology. This led to a series of heated confrontations, often marked by violence and intrigue, as different groups vied to have their beliefs enshrined as orthodox.

At the heart of these conflicts were several key figures, including the powerful Roman emperors and a cadre of influential bishops who commanded the loyalty of armed militias. These individuals engaged in a high-stakes game of political maneuvering, using a combination of cunning, persuasion, and brute force to advance their respective agendas.

One of the most pivotal events was the Council of Ephesus in 431 CE, where the question of Christ's nature took center stage. The debate centered around the relationship between Jesus' divine and human attributes, with some factions advocating for a more unified conception of his identity, while others argued for a clearer distinction between the two. The outcome of this council had far-reaching consequences, as the victorious faction's interpretation became the foundation for mainstream Christian theology.

Similarly, the Council of Chalcedon in 451 CE further solidified the church's position on the nature of Christ, rejecting certain interpretations as heretical and cementing the doctrine of the hypostatic union – the belief that Jesus is both fully divine and fully human. This decision, too, was the result of political wrangling and the strategic deployment of imperial power.

These battles over Christology were not mere academic exercises; they were fiercely contested as each faction sought to gain the upper hand and shape the future of the church. The stakes were high, as the victors would not only determine the theological underpinnings of Christianity but also the very structure and authority of the church itself.

In the end, it was the faction aligned with the Roman emperors and their military might that emerged triumphant, paving the way for the rise of the papacy and the solidification of Christian orthodoxy as we know it today. Jenkins' account highlights the profound irony that the beliefs and practices of the modern church are in many ways the product of political maneuvering and military force, rather than the result of a smooth, linear progression of theological development.

Jesus Wars is a masterful exploration of this pivotal moment in church history, revealing the profound implications of what amounts to an accident of history. By shedding light on the political machinations that forever altered the course of Christianity, Jenkins invites us to consider the fragility of our religious and institutional foundations, and the profound impact that a handful of powerful individuals can have on the trajectory of entire civilizations.

product information: